The best two factor authentication method for most people is a passkey or a hardware security key, because both are phishing-resistant: they only work on the real website, so a fake login page can’t capture them. An authenticator app is a strong second choice. SMS text codes are the weakest option, but they’re still far better than having no second factor at all.

Most account takeovers don’t involve genius hackers. They involve a stolen password, often from an old data breach, plus a second factor that was easy to trick or intercept. Attackers send a realistic login page, collect your password and the six-digit code you just received, and use both within seconds. Or they talk your carrier into moving your phone number to their SIM card.

The stakes keep rising. The FBI’s latest Internet Crime Report counted more than $20 billion in reported cybercrime losses for 2025, and crypto exchanges remain prime targets for account takeovers after the Binance breach. Picking the right second factor is one of the highest-value security moves you can make, and it takes about ten minutes per account.

Key takeaways

  • Phishing-resistant methods (passkeys and hardware security keys) are the gold standard.
  • Authenticator apps beat SMS because codes can’t be redirected through your phone number.
  • SMS is vulnerable to SIM swapping and interception, but it’s still better than nothing.
  • Protect your email account first; it’s the reset key to everything else.
  • Always store backup codes somewhere safe and set up more than one method.

What is two-factor authentication?

Two-factor authentication (2FA) is a login method that requires two different kinds of proof: something you know, like a password, plus something you have, like your phone or a security key, or something you are, like a fingerprint. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) is the broader term. The point is that a stolen password alone isn’t enough to get in.

Not all second factors are equal, though. The key difference is whether a method can be phished, meaning whether an attacker can trick you into handing it over on a fake site.

Which is the best two factor authentication method? Ranked

Rank Method Phishing-resistant? SIM-swap resistant? Convenience
1 Hardware security key (FIDO2/WebAuthn) Yes Yes Medium: carry a key
1 Passkey (device-bound or synced) Yes Yes High: face or fingerprint
3 Push notification with number matching Partly Yes High
4 Authenticator app (TOTP codes) No Yes Medium
5 SMS or voice code No No High
5 Email code No Depends on email security Medium

The US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency recommends phishing-resistant MFA as the strongest option on its MFA guidance page, and has urged people to move away from SMS codes where they can. NIST’s digital identity guidelines treat SMS as a “restricted” authenticator because of its known weaknesses.

What are passkeys, and are they safer than passwords?

A passkey is a login credential based on public-key cryptography that replaces a password: your device stores a private key and proves your identity to a website with a fingerprint, face scan or device PIN, without ever sending a secret that could be stolen. Passkeys are built on standards from the FIDO Alliance and are supported by Apple, Google and Microsoft.

Why they’re so strong: a passkey is cryptographically tied to the real website’s domain. If you land on g00gle-login.com, your device simply has no passkey for it, so there’s nothing to phish. There’s also no password to reuse or leak in a breach.

Synced vs device-bound passkeys

Synced passkeys back up through your Apple, Google or password-manager account, so you don’t lose them with your phone. That makes the security of that cloud account critical. Device-bound passkeys, such as those stored on a hardware security key, never leave the device; they’re the strictest option and are favored for high-security accounts.

Authenticator app vs SMS: which is better?

An authenticator app, such as Google Authenticator, Microsoft Authenticator, Authy or the one built into many password managers, generates a fresh six-digit code every 30 seconds on your device. SMS sends a code over the phone network.

Authenticator apps win for one big reason: they’re not tied to your phone number. In a SIM swap attack, a criminal convinces your carrier to move your number to their SIM, then receives your SMS codes. That’s a common route into crypto and email accounts. An authenticator app on your physical phone is immune to that trick.

But neither is phishing-resistant. A convincing fake page can still ask for your authenticator code and relay it to the real site in real time. That’s why passkeys and security keys sit above both.

What about push notifications?

“Was this you? Approve / Deny” prompts are convenient but vulnerable to “MFA fatigue” attacks, where criminals spam approval requests hoping you tap yes. Number matching, where you type a number shown on the login screen, makes this much harder. Never approve a prompt you didn’t trigger.

How to set up the strongest 2FA, account by account

  1. Start with your primary email. Whoever controls your inbox can reset most of your other passwords. Add a passkey and, if possible, a hardware key.
  2. Then your phone carrier. Add a port-out PIN or number lock to block SIM swaps.
  3. Then money accounts: banks, brokerages, crypto exchanges, PayPal. Use a passkey or security key where offered, otherwise an authenticator app.
  4. Then your password manager and Apple, Google or Microsoft account, since they may sync your passkeys.
  5. Remove SMS as a fallback where the service lets you, once a stronger method is working. Otherwise attackers just choose the weaker option.
  6. Save backup codes offline or in your password manager, and register a second key or device.

If you hold crypto, combine this with offline storage of long-term holdings; our guide to hot wallets vs cold wallets explains why exchange account security is only half the picture.

Our take: what this means for you

For most people, the best two factor authentication method is the one you’ll actually keep using, and passkeys win on both counts. Use them everywhere they’re offered. They’re both the most secure option and, for most people, the easiest. For your email and any account holding serious money, add two hardware security keys, one on your keyring and one stored safely at home. They cost a few dozen dollars each and shut down the attacks that drain most accounts.

Use an authenticator app for everything else, and treat SMS as a last resort. What we wouldn’t do: turn off 2FA because a stronger method feels like a hassle. SMS has real flaws, but it still stops the huge volume of automated attacks using leaked passwords. Pair all of this with a password manager; we look at the trade-offs in are password managers safe? And brush up on the scam tactics in how to spot phishing scams, because no technology helps if you read a code to a stranger on the phone.

Frequently asked questions

Can two-factor authentication be hacked?

Some methods can be bypassed. SMS codes can be intercepted via SIM swaps, and both SMS and app codes can be phished through fake login pages that relay them in real time. Passkeys and hardware security keys resist these attacks because they only work on the genuine website.

What happens if I lose my phone with my authenticator app?

Use your saved backup codes or a second registered method to log in, then set up 2FA again on a new device. Some authenticator apps offer encrypted cloud backup. Without backups, recovery can mean a slow identity-verification process with each service.

Are passkeys better than an authenticator app?

Yes, for security and usually for convenience. Passkeys are phishing-resistant and replace both the password and the code. Authenticator app codes can still be tricked out of you on a fake site.

Is SMS two-factor authentication still worth using?

Yes, if it’s the only option a site offers. It blocks most automated attacks that rely on stolen passwords. Upgrade to an app or passkey whenever the service supports it, and protect your phone number with a carrier PIN.

Do I need a hardware security key?

Most people don’t strictly need one if they use passkeys, but a key adds strong protection for email, financial and crypto accounts. Buy two so you have a backup, and register both on each account.